Nonadditive Interactions

If LD50M measured in the laboratory is less than that computed by equation (19.19) (or S < 1.0), the two toxins interact in a positive way. This is called synergistic interaction, also called "more than additive.'' Another type of positive interaction is when A is essentially nontoxic by itself but causes an increase in the toxicity of B when present. This is called potentiation (although this term is sometimes also used in the literature to indicate synergistic interaction).

Unfortunately for the additive model, synergistic interactions are common, as is to be expected, especially for an effect such as lethality. This is because, even if the two toxins have completely independent effects, one may sicken the organisms, making them more vulnerable to the effect of the other. The models of equations (19.19) or (19.21) could be extended to nonlinear interactions by adding terms involving products of toxicities and fitting the coefficients by regression. However, data on mixture toxicity are hard to come by. Furthermore, they may not be consistent at different effect levels. That is, if there is positive interaction between the LD50s of two compounds, it is not necessarily true that there will be positive interaction to a similar extent, or at all, in their LD0j values, let alone at the 10~6 risk level.

In an exception to what was noted about organophosphate interactions above, malathion interacts synergistically with some other organophosphates, as much as 50 times as strong in combination. As Rachel Carson put it in Silent Spring: "1/100 of the lethal dose of each compound may be fatal when the two are combined.''

Ethanol and carbon tetrachloride have a synergistic effect on the liver, and tobacco smoke and asbestos interact in lung cancer. In the latter case the interaction was defined differently from that above. It was observed that asbestos workers who did not smoke experienced a fivefold increase in their risk of lung cancer, and cigarette smokers who did not work with asbestos had an 11-fold increase. However, asbestos workers who smoked experienced a 55-fold increase in lung cancer rate. Thus, the interaction here is defined in terms of additivity of risk instead of additivity of toxicity. An example of poten-tiation is isopropanol, which does not harm the liver by itself but greatly increases the toxicity of carbon tetrachloride.

Positive interactions can be caused by a number of mechanisms, including:

• By interfering with an enzyme that detoxifies other compound

• By affecting absorption, blood transport, or excretion

• By reacting to form a more toxic substance (e.g., nitrites and some amines react in the stomach to form carcinogenic nitrosomines)

• Induction of biotransformation enzymes

If two toxins interact, resulting in a measured toxic effect less than that predicted by the additive model, this is a negative, or antagonistic, interaction, also called "less than additive.'' Antagonistic interactions are detected when the LD50 value of a mixture is greater than predicted by equations (19.19) or (19.21), or S > 1.0. Some antidotes take advantage of antagonistic interactions. Mechanisms causing negative interactions include:

• Chemical reactions, such as complexation between EDTA and heavy metals

• Inhibition of bioactivation (e.g., toluene competitively inhibits the enzymes that biotransform benzene)

• Two toxins produce opposite effects, such as central nervous system depressants and stimulants

• Competition for the same receptor

• Induction of detoxification enzymes

Enzyme induction was mentioned above as a mechanism of both positive and negative interactions. The cytochrome P450 enzymes are a common target of induction. Benzene can interact positively with other solvents by inducing cytochrome P450.

Example 19.4 Doudoroff (1952) measured the 8-hour LC50 of zinc and copper to fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas), obtaining LC50;zinc = 8 mg/L and LC50;copper = 0.2mg/L. He then tested a mixture with a fixed 1.0 mg/L zinc and varied the copper concentration to obtain the LC50;M . This was found to occur at a copper concentration of 0.025 mg/L. What kind of interaction is this? Answer

Was this article helpful?

0 0
10 Ways To Fight Off Cancer

10 Ways To Fight Off Cancer

Learning About 10 Ways Fight Off Cancer Can Have Amazing Benefits For Your Life The Best Tips On How To Keep This Killer At Bay Discovering that you or a loved one has cancer can be utterly terrifying. All the same, once you comprehend the causes of cancer and learn how to reverse those causes, you or your loved one may have more than a fighting chance of beating out cancer.

Get My Free Ebook


Post a comment